One Firm. Every Answer. Serving Toledo Since 2002.
A trusted law firm in Sylvania handling family law, criminal defense, bankruptcy, and estate planning — so you don't have to figure out where to turn first.
Over two decades of northwest Ohio court experience. A team of attorneys who answer their own phones.
At Mahaffey & Associates, you get a full-service firm at one address on Central Avenue — not a referral to someone else's office and not a paralegal who doesn't know your name. Whether you're navigating a custody dispute, facing a criminal charge, overwhelmed by debt, or planning your estate, we'll tell you exactly where you stand and what comes next — starting with a free conversation, not a bill.
Our attorneys — Ty Mahaffey, Jennifer Fogle, and Austin Klapp — practice across all four core areas, so the right person is always available for your matter.
What Brings Most Families and Individuals Through Our Door
Every practice area we handle arrives at a moment of stress. Here's where we can help.
Louisiana work injury claims & denials
Divorce, dissolution of marriage, child custody, child support, spousal support, and juvenile matters — handled by attorneys who know Lucas County Court of Common Pleas and Sylvania Municipal Court inside and out.
Family Law
Divorce, dissolution of marriage, child custody, child support, spousal support, and juvenile matters — handled by attorneys who know Lucas County Court of Common Pleas and Sylvania Municipal Court inside and out.
Criminal Defense
From OVI charges to felony defense, we represent clients throughout the Toledo metro with straightforward answers about what the charge means and what the realistic path forward looks like.
Bankruptcy
Chapter 7, Chapter 13, and wage garnishment relief for individuals and families ready to stop the financial bleeding and move forward. We work with the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Toledo regularly.
Estate Planning
Wills, trusts, powers of attorney, and probate guidance for northwest Ohio families who want their wishes documented and their people protected.
Why Toledo-Area Residents Call Us First
Ty Mahaffey has practiced law in northwest Ohio since 2002 — he knows the local courts, the local judges, and how cases move in this region.
Customer testimonials on Google
Serving Sylvania, Toledo, and the Surrounding Communities
Our office sits on Central Avenue in Sylvania, just off I-475 — accessible from Toledo, Maumee, Perrysburg, Oregon, Ottawa Hills, Whitehouse, Holland, and Monclova Township. We also serve clients in Wood County communities including Perrysburg and Bowling Green, and throughout Fulton County.
If you're not sure whether we cover your area, call us. Chances are, we do.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a lawyer, or can I handle this on my own?
That depends on what you're facing. Many people come to us unsure whether their situation warrants legal help. A free consultation gives you a clear answer without any obligation — and in most cases, knowing your options costs you nothing.
Does your firm handle cases outside of Sylvania?
Yes. We serve clients throughout Lucas County and the broader Toledo metro, including Maumee, Perrysburg, Oregon, and surrounding communities. We also handle matters in Wood County and Fulton County.
What does a free consultation actually include?
You'll speak directly with one of our attorneys — not a receptionist or intake coordinator. We'll review your situation, explain the relevant legal process in plain terms, and give you an honest assessment of your options. No pressure, no clock running.
Can I work with the same attorney throughout my case?
Yes. Our team structure is designed so that clients work directly with their attorney rather than being handed off to support staff. You'll know your attorney's name by the end of the first call.
What if my situation involves more than one legal issue?
That's exactly why we built a full-service firm. A divorce can involve custody, support, and estate planning updates all at once. A criminal charge can affect a custody case. Having attorneys across all four practice areas under one roof means nothing falls through the cracks.
Ready to Talk to a Real Attorney?
We offer free consultations, and we’ll never pressure you to sign anything. Whether you just need answers or you’re ready to get started, we’re here to help.
